Third Homework Set Answers

4(f) (i) To fill in the table, we must find the pattern of squares of side length r = 1/2n needed to cover the shape. The horizontal line needs 2n boxes. The x = 0 vertical line needs 2n - 1 boxes. The x = 1/2 vertical line needs 2n - 1 boxes. The x = 1/4 vertical line needs 2n - 1 boxes. ... The x = 1/2n-1 vertical line needs 2n - 1 boxes. All the other vertical lines are covered by an additional column of 2n - 1 boxes.
   
On the left is the completed table, on the right is the graph.
  r    N(r)    1/r    Log(1/r)    Log(N(r))  
1/242 0.3010.602
1/4134 0.6021.114
1/8368 0.9031.556
1/169116 1.2041.959
1/3221832 1.5052.338
1/6450564 1.8062.703
   
The first two points do not appear to fall along athe same line as the remaining four. The slope of this line approximates the box-counting dimension. We measure dim = (2.703 - 2.338)/(1.806 - 1.505) = 1.033.
(ii) The pattern of the box counts is
1/2nN(2n)
1/22 + 1 + 1
1/44 + 3 + 3 + 3
1/88 + 7 + 7 + 7 + 7
1/1616 + 15 + 15 + 15 + 15 + 15
In general, for boxes of side length 1/2n we have
N(1/2n)= 2n + (n + 1)(2n - 1)
= 2n(n + 2) - (n + 1)
= 2n(n + 2 - (n+1)/2n)
Then the box-counting dimension is the limit
db = limn → ∞Log(2n(n + 2 - (n+1)/2n))/Log(2n)
= limn → ∞Log(2n)/Log(2n) + limn → ∞Log(n + 2 - (n+1)/2n)/Log(2n)
= 1
(iii) The results of (i) and (ii) are close, but not identical because (i) was not calculated with boxes small enough to detect the limiting value.

Return to Homework 3 Practice.